The Reframe, Issue 04: The Program Was Never the Product

Most of us built our careers on the program. I did. For a lot of coaches it’s the hardest-won skill we have. Years learning energy systems, progressions, how to dose a stressor for one specific person. It’s what separated us from the template and the app, and it’s what clients paid for. So when someone says AI is coming for coaching, the natural reaction is a little defensive. A machine can spit out a generic plan. It can’t write what I write for my client, because it doesn’t know my client.

We just got back from our OPEX Coaches Retreat in Portugal. Thirty coaches from all over the world, four days in Portugal, and a big share of our conversations were thought experiments on exactly this. I would like to reframe it a bit.

AI isn’t coming for your coaching. It’s coming for the part of coaching you were proudest of, and that part was never the product…well, for some of us.

This isn’t a new conversation for us. James was talking about machines writing programs back in 2016. We started bringing it to our coaches when ChatGPT showed up, and in 2024 James said it to a bunch of coaches live on a call: “machines will do better program design than we have ever done.” That was a bit uncomfortable for a lot of coaches, and still is.

What changed is the timeline. On the show a few weeks ago I said that a machine with the right context can already build program designs and nutrition prescriptions better than a human. Not in 3 years, not in 1 year, not in 5. Right now.

Then I asked James the harder question. “Can a machine coach behavior?” I expected a no. He said, “I think it can and I think it will.” Phones have been teaching people how to behave for fifteen years, and most of what passes for a relationship online isn’t one. In his words, “people think they know me cuz they watch me on Zoom. You don’t know me.” Highlight of the pod if you haven’t heard it…worth the listen haha.

So the line isn’t human versus machine. It’s real versus not real. Back to James in 2024: “the reason why we will win is that we are real.” The program is information. The coach who has sat across the table from someone and knows why they quit on Thursdays is not.

Where it fits: your value proposition, before your program design. We’ve started splitting it with our coaches into hard skills and soft skills. At a CCP office hours a few weeks ago, I asked coaches to picture their value as a bucket filled to 100 percent, then tell me how much of it was writing great programs. Answers came back at 50, 60, 70, even 80 percent. Same advice to every one of them. Reallocate. Now.

Reallocate to the consult, the assessment, the lifestyle plan, the weekly check in. The conversations where you find out what someone wants underneath what they said. You can spend a lifetime getting better at understanding people. Most of what we know about exercise and nutrition is already good enough.

In Portugal we opened day one with two anonymous cards. “What part of your coaching week would you happily never do again?” and “What part would you never hand to anyone?” Here were the results:

Try: answer those same two questions this week, five things on each. Everything on the first list, hand to a machine and check its work. Everything on the second list is where the hours you get back should go. If writing programs lands on the second list, ask yourself whether it’s there because your client needs you to do it, or because you need to.

Give the machine the program. Spend what it gives back teaching your clients how to stop needing you.

This came out of conversations with James on Frameworks, Episodes 51 and 54, and a week with our coaches in Portugal.

Your next step

Apply for the OPEX Method here.

The application is short. The call with our education team is not a sales call. It is a fit assessment, and they will tell you honestly if this is right for you. If you want to go deeper, Carl has opened 20-minute slots on his calendar this week for coaches considering the program.

Go Deeper Into the Legacy

Want the complete picture of James's methodology, story, and coaching wisdom? Explore the OPEX Legacy Collection:

Next
Next

AI Can Write Workouts. What Makes a Great Coach?